- Joined
- Nov 4, 2025
- Posts
- 8,210
- Reputation
- 23,450
The Best of the Best (BOTB) Selection Criteria
To earn a spot in the BOTB section, your thread must represent the absolute pinnacle of information on the forum. Meeting the baseline requirements does not guarantee selection; your thread must actively stand out in substance, execution, and integrity.
- The thread must be the absolute best available resource on the forum for that topic. Sub-topics or weaker variations of existing BOTB threads will not qualify.
- Content must be strictly educational, actionable, or instructional. It must fully deliver on its title without relying on "common-sense" filler.
- The topic must be substantial enough to warrant deep exploration. Threads under 800 words are rarely considered.
-Logical Consensus: For evolving topics, arguments must be built on sound reasoning and mechanistic logic rather than individual bias or weak evidence (e.g., super small animal studies, forum rumors).
-Professional Formatting: Threads must use a clean, scannable hierarchy (clear sections, bolding, and headings) to ensure a polished aesthetic.
-Accessible Clarity: Write with impeccable grammar, flow, and punctuation. The language should be sharp and accessible; any highly specialized or niche terms must be clearly defined.
-.Human-First Content: The vast majority of the writing must be your own. Direct copy-pasting without referencing the source or article or heavy lifting from other sources is an automatic disqualification.
-Strict AI Policy: Pure AI-generated text is banned.
-The "Living Document" Rule: A thread's BOTB status is not permanent. It will be demoted to the Former BOTB Megathread if a superior thread on the topic is published.
-Misinformation Zero-Tolerance: If a thread is found to contain significant misinformation, it will be removed entirely from the archives. Authors are always encouraged to update, correct, and resubmit their work to reclaim status.
-Final Discretion: Inclusion is ultimately at the discretion of the board to maintain the section's prestige.
The approval board: @surgerymax @the wizard @Nardicus @Mandy @fent @FoidSlayer @Dysregulated

